Three Waters Proceeds

Three Waters Proceeds
Tuesday 21 December, 2021
Seldom has a Minister for Local Government shown such resolve. The Hon. Nanaia Mahuta originally shrugged off wide-spread concern about the Government’s three waters reform proposals proposing to introduce legislation into Parliament in early December to support what she describes as a compelling case for reform. However, a recently announced ‘pause’ has allowed more time to take into account sector feedback and the legislation will be introduced after the end of February next year.
Government will proceed with Three Waters Reform
By now everyone will be familiar with the Government proposal, which involves the transfer of all council-owned water services to four water service entities to be owned, but not controlled, by the local authorities within their boundaries. The Three Waters Reform Programme is a response to what has been described as the mounting evidence of the challenges facing three waters service delivery nationally. The Programme has already resulted in the enactment of the Water Services Act 2021, the main purpose of which is to ensure that drinking water suppliers provide safe drinking water to consumers, and the establishment of Taumata Arowai as the dedicated regulator of drinking water, wastewater, and stormwater.
Not everyone is happy with the Minister’s proposals. After an eight-week consultation process in August and October involving local authorities, iwi/Maori, LGNZ and Taituara and others, 75% of the submissions stated they did not support the proposed model put forward by the Government. While many submitters acknowledged there was a case for change, a few Councils noted their overall opposition to the reform. The concerns expressed included:
- The complexity of the proposed model
- Loss of local decision-making
- How the water services entities will interact with local government planning
- The inclusion of stormwater
- Doubts about accuracy and relevance of the modelling undertaken
- Insufficient engagement and public consultation
- The need for better alignment with resource management reforms and the Future for Local Government review.
The Minister is unmoved. In her announcement on 27 October confirming the creation of four publicly owned water entities she said:
“The case for change is too compelling to ignore. It is clear that without the establishment of these publicly owned entities we will continue to see a frail network and contaminated water in many communities. To delay will only push the problem on, increase future household costs and put livelihoods at risk.”
What happens next?
Two separate Bills are proposed. The Water Services Entities Bill, now to be introduced after the end of February 2022, and the Economic and Consumer Protection Bill expected to be enacted at the end of 2023. Although the Select Committee process will provide an opportunity to get public feedback on the reforms, it seems unlikely that there will be any change to the broad structure proposed. It is worth noting that while still leader of the National Party Judith Collins stated that National would repeal the legislation if National was elected at the next election in 2023, which would appear possible as the new water service entities are not scheduled to become operational until mid-2024.
The following timetable has been set for progressing the reforms –
October to December 2021
Cabinet decisions on reform pathway. National Transition Unit Board Chairs and members appointed MBIE Economic Regulation and consumer protections public consultation begins. Technical working groups to refine reform details begins.
January to June 2022
Water Service Entities Bill and Select committee process – public submissions and hearings – until June 2022. Technical working groups to refine reform details. National Transition Unit consultation engagement with local authorities. Cabinet to consider economic regulation and consumer protection, and pricing/charging.
July – December 2022
First $500m of ‘better off’ funding available (July 2022). Water Service Entities (Implementation) Bill and Select committee process – public submissions and hearings – until June 2023.
January – June 2023
Economic and Consumer Protection Bill (TBC) and Select committee process – public submissions and hearings – until December 2023.
July 2024
‘No worse off’ and remaining ‘Better off’ funding available. All water service entities operational (1 July 2024).
We will continue to provide updates on this process as it unfolds.
Related Articles

Councils challenge to transfer of water services rejected in High Court
Thursday 30 March, 2023

When the rubber hits the road - All aboard Aotearoa's challenge
Tuesday 11 October, 2022

Declarations that an Enactment Inconsistent with Bill of Rights
Tuesday 11 October, 2022

Proposed mandatory consideration of specific Māori representation
Tuesday 11 October, 2022

New Regime for Protected Disclosures (Whistleblower legislation)
Wednesday 29 June, 2022

Operative plans and proposed plans: what to do when there is a significant policy shift?
Wednesday 30 March, 2022

Notices of requirement are relevant for resource consent applications
Wednesday 30 March, 2022

Avoidance policies reign in the wake of King Salmon, but what do they require?
Wednesday 30 March, 2022

Court gives guidance on consultation and decision-making process
Wednesday 30 March, 2022

Cultural evidence and the continued draw of the overall judgment
Tuesday 21 December, 2021

Fluoridation debate lifted from shoulders of local government
Tuesday 21 December, 2021

Will new housing density rules increase contributions for developers?
Thursday 28 October, 2021

Judicial review of Hamilton City Council's development contributions policy
Tuesday 5 October, 2021

Lease of Wanaka Airport set aside due to insufficient consultation
Tuesday 15 June, 2021

What if an abatement notice requires you to breach the Resource Management Act?
Tuesday 15 June, 2021

“No ‘wine-ing’ covenants” declined for a subdivision consent in Gibbston Valley
Tuesday 15 June, 2021

From car parking fine to judicial review of a council’s code of conduct
Tuesday 15 June, 2021

Councils remain liable for compliance of contractors with the RMA
Thursday 18 March, 2021

Randerson Report released: New Direction for Resource Management
Wednesday 5 August, 2020

Could companies be liable to the public for the harm caused by their emissions?
Tuesday 10 March, 2020

Avoiding double penalties when sentencing a company and director
Thursday 23 April, 2020

Can an easement be granted over an esplanade reserve for a commercial activity?
Thursday 12 December, 2019

Draft National Policy Statement for Freshwater Management 2019 for consultation
Thursday 3 October, 2019

Local authority requiring monetary contributions on designations
Thursday 20 June, 2019

Bella Vista: MBIE Report highlights failure to perform statutory functions
Tuesday 9 April, 2019

Recent decision on "affected persons" highlights the importance of context
Wednesday 28 November, 2018

High Court finds Council liable in negligence for damage from fallen tree
Thursday 27 September, 2018

Court upholds sensible approach to local authority works on private property
Tuesday 24 July, 2018

Must Councils accept an assertion that a person is ‘suitably qualified'?
Friday 9 March, 2018
